I have hesitated to write this post for some time. And in my hesitation I have waited even longer, thinking perhaps that I needed to know why I was reluctant to hit “Publish” but recently I changed my mind and decided that sometimes it’s good to talk about things that you don’t have the answers to. So here goes.
I am not interested in reading any “how-to” or “help” book on parenting. There, I’ve said it.
At 16 weeks pregnant I know many of my friends were already well entrenched in at least half a dozen different manuals, books, websites, etc.–reading up on what’s going on inside, how to prepare for an infant, and how to raise a young child. But not me. In fact, I’ve gone so far as to even avoid bringing up the topic of parenting and childbirth in conversation with other adults. Am I being obstinate or self-righteous? Do I think I know it all? Am I foolish for not seeking the advice and wisdom of a marketplace of trained “experts”? Perhaps. But I don’t think so.
It’s sad to me that children can so easily divide us. Every parent has their tried-and-true method for just about any instance. Where to give birth. Plenty of opinions about that. Pain meds or no pain meds. Heard a few opinions about this. What about the topic of discipline? Spanking? Time out? Should a child be rocked to sleep? Should a child eat honey? What about meat? Oh and what about vaccines? The number of scenarios are endless and it makes my head spin just thinking about it. And boy are we passionate about our tried-and-true methods. This one works. That one doesn’t. When it comes down to it though, isn’t every child different? So won’t every parent have to adapt a little and doesn’t this mean that there really can’t be ONE way to raise ALL children? B and I joked the other day that we should join the chorus of voices and publish our own book on childbirth and early parenting. It wouldn’t cost much because it would be a pretty thin paperback. You’d open it up and it would say:
There is no one right way. It is different for every one and it will look different for every one.
(BTW, this quote works for our book on marriage as well. Publishing date TBD)
Mostly I made the conscious choice not to read a bunch of baby literature because my goal in this first pregnancy was to be as relaxed as possible. I want to savor each moment, before the birth and after. And by savor, I mean live those moments and not just fill my head with worries and conflicting advice. I know, I know…this is so counterintuitive for a literary buff who spends her time buried in books. Yet somehow when I even gaze down the aisle at the bookstore that is loaded with methodologies for parenting and such my whole body seems to tense and so, I turn and hustle over to the aisle with my beloved Jane Austen novels instead.
I will point out however, that this does not mean B and I haven’t discussed our views on childbirth and parenting. We’ve talked those subjects into the ground. We’ve rung out of them every ounce of juice possible. This activity I fully support and engage in because what can be more important than being on the same page as your spouse when it comes to such life-altering issues? The last thing I want is to discover as I go into labor that B is ridiculously uncomfortable with us giving birth to our first born in a tub in the kitchen or when our child acts out for the first time and I find that, unbeknownst to me, B was raised to handle the outburst one way and I was raised completely the opposite and now we’ve managed to confuse our poor misbehaving kid and still nothing has been resolved. No, I definitely appreciate the long talks we have been having.
I guess ultimately my philosophy of parenting at this present stage of life is that we will learn what works and what doesn’t, we will cherish our child and love them with everything we have. We will strive to keep open hearts and minds and realize that this is a tiny individual who is entirely unique and cannot be fit into a definition that some doctor, therapist, or family expert has written somewhere at some time without every meeting our child.
And yes, this probably means that we will break all the rules. I’m ok with that.
Oh friend! I love you and your way of thinking. I appreciate this so, so much. As you said, there are so many divisions over who may be right and who may be wrong. Truly, the crux of this issue is that *unique* families and babies will need *different* methods and approaches… You and B know this well; you’ll be wonderful lovers and caretakers of this new life. So happy for you xx
I love this philosophy. I will confess to being one of those who read the books. I think that was mainly because everybody handed them to me as soon as we found out I was expecting. I did take bits from each book though and we came up with our own plan. We also agreed that our plan was flexible and if a sudden change occurred, we would go with it. After all, the most important thing is having a healthy baby. Enjoy this relaxing period of your life. One the little one arrives, you will have trouble remembering what it was like when it was just the two of you. Congratulations and give in to those cravings.
I love this. Glad to hear you guys are talking (that’s the most important) but also glad to hear you’re not reading. I think those books only add fuel to the proverbial fires of fear and anxiety. You’re looking awesome, and the baby will live a better life because of it.
Alyssa, I really enjoyed reading this blog! I love to see how our friendship started as childhood friends and is now spilling over into the sacred comerady of parenthood. I apologize for my long-winded reply…what can I say, I’m Italian.
“To read or not to read.” …I think that a lot comes down to personality and how one handles new endeavors in life in general. A good mom friend, ‘Staci,’ and I had a conversation about this topic a couple of weeks ago. She told me how her best friend, who is six months pregnant, has been reading every parenting/baby book on the shelf and has even gone so far as to take “baby preparation” classes that teach you basic baby care. At first I was surprised to hear about the prep work her friend was doing…it seemed a little extreme to me. However, Staci explained that her friend did this in nearly every aspect of her life: work, school, hobbies, etc. When learning something new, some people enjoy putting in the research and finding what has worked well. I don’t think that reading the books and doing the “research” means that one doesn’t view their child as entirely unique. I don’t think –well, I hope — that parents don’t view their kids as robots to be ‘handled’ or ‘figured out.’ Where’s the fun in that? I think for some it is scarier to come into a new venture unprepared or without talking to someone who has “been there.” Perhaps for others, this new step in life — marriage, a baby, etc — is a new journey, a clean slate begging for the explorer’s fingerprints alone. I was/am a mix of both: I didn’t read a bunch of baby how-to books before my children were born, but I did love my (paraphrased) “What Baby is Growing This Week” book (she’s got fingernails now? Cool!)
After the baby shower gift bags had been tucked away and my first child was born, I did have a crazy “Oh-my-God-I-have-a-child-for-whom-I-am-responsible-and-I-have-to-keep-her-alive” moment, which I feel was necessary, scary, and awesome, all at the same time. It made me realize that I would do anything, ANYTHING for this precious life the Lord had sovereignly entrusted me with. It also made me realize that there were things in my childhood that I didn’t want repeated, and so I sought advice from other, experienced mothers I respected and who showed fruit in their lives worth bearing. If they recommended a read, I would give it a whirl. Did I do 100% of what they recommended? No. If I did that, I would have to give up cherry coke and homeschool my children from birth (in cloth diapers) while simultaneously running a thriving organic soap business that was powered by solar energy alone….and that’s just not me.
I totally agree that if you and hubs are on the same page, that is super important. The most important thing, for me, was/is knowing that I can’t be a good parent in my own strength, anyway. I just can’t. My human love will give out everytime. I daily, daily have to surrender to the Father and rely on His crazy, relentless, supernatural love and grace to love my kids through this human vessel, and that’s something no wealth of books could ever give me.
Thank you, thank you ,thank you for your lovely responses. If I am being totally honest I haven’t entirely shunned reading.
(how could I?) I have been given one or two books that I have cracked occasionally but overall, it’s been fun to let go of the potential stress and just enjoy this new stage.
I agree with “happilyperryed”. Books are not all that bad. Those”self help” books are just that, help. They are not demanding that you raise your kid a certain way, just giving you advice from someone who has done it already. But it sounds like you and Bryan have it all figured out-good luck. And marriage experts, too?! Well, you are your mother’s daughter…
Avery-alyssa’s-brother, is that you??? I used to play pranks pranks on you when you were eleven! I hear you are all grown up and married with children…congrats!
Alyssa, I have one word to describe what you have written: AMEN!!!!!!! So happy for both of you and delighted that you are choosing this way of thinking. Yes, every little one is unique and has their own personality and, yes, every pregnancy is different. I enjoyed being pregnant (except for the morning sickness!) and, like you, chose to just relax. Praying for a wonderful experience and safe delivery for you! Congratulations!!
Barbie,
Thanks so much for your sweet words. We are so thrilled to welcome this new life into the world in January. (I felt the baby move for the first time a few nights ago and it was precious)
BUT HOW WILL YOU EVER CHOOSE A NAME if you don’t read the Baby Name Books?!?!
Hey Alyssa. I think your perspective on this is great. I tend to over-research everything and sometimes it makes my head spin with options. I think it’s great if you feel that you can trust your own parenting intuition to figure out what works for you guys and what feels right to you. Plus, if you ever get stumped by something your child is doing, it’s never hard to find another parent who is willing to share their opinion on the matter, LOL! I ended up skimming several books (mostly about sleep training) and basically made up my own system. I found the books helpful to a degree and it was particularly helpful for me to read about how other parents of twins handled their daily routine, sleeping, feeding, etc. I don’t particularly enjoy reading so I actually had my mom read most of the book on sleep training and then she and I would talk about what she learned. I do have to say that there was one book that I really enjoyed reading while I was pregnant and I even caught Howie reading over my shoulder a few times. It’s called “The Girlfriends Guide to Pregnancy” and it was really funny and refreshingly honest. It tells you about all the weird and strange things that are going on with your body and helps you to not take anything too seriously. It’s all the stuff about pregnancy that only your best girlfriend isn’t embarrassed to tell you about. Anyway, just thought I would mention that one if you interested in some pretty light pregnancy reading. I am so excited for you guys to be parents and I have no doubt that you will be amazing parents.